UN experts raise concerns over Canada’s oversight and safeguards for incarcerated individuals


“United Nations Experts Critique Canada’s Justice System

A recent report from the UN Working Group on Arbitrary Detention has highlighted several areas where Canada’s justice system is falling short. From trial delays to the treatment of Indigenous peoples in the legal system, there are clear areas in need of improvement.

Issues with Immigration Detention

One major concern raised by the panel is the lack of oversight in Canada’s immigration detention system. The report suggests that there should be a cap on how long foreigners can be detained without charge, as well as the need for more accountability within the Canada Border Services Agency. With vulnerable individuals interacting with border guards, it is vital to have proper mechanisms in place to prevent abuses and mistakes.

Challenges Facing Indigenous People

The report also criticized the handling of Indigenous peoples within the justice system. Initiatives meant to reduce the disproportionate incarceration rates of Indigenous individuals are not being effectively implemented or funded. The panel specifically mentioned the shortcomings of Gladue reports, which are meant to provide courts with a better understanding of how colonization has impacted an offender’s life. The process of creating these reports can often be traumatic for the accused.

Positive Recognition

Despite these criticisms, the UN officials did acknowledge some positive aspects of Canada’s justice system. They praised initiatives that have successfully reduced incarceration rates, such as reforms for youth in custody in Ontario. Additionally, they commended the overall behavior of police officers in terms of excessive force and arrest procedures.

Moving Forward

It is clear that there is work to be done in order to ensure a more equitable and just legal system in Canada. Oversight and accountability are key factors in preventing violations of international law and ensuring fair treatment for all individuals. By addressing the issues raised by the UN panel and working to improve the areas of concern, Canada can move towards a justice system that truly upholds the rights and dignity of all its citizens.”



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here