“UBC and UVIC Mandate Race-Based Professor Hiring: Discrimination or Affirmative Action?
The University of British Columbia and the University of Victoria have recently implemented race-based hiring initiatives as part of their diversity, equity, and inclusion agendas. This means that both institutions are mandating that new professor hires be black. While this move is being lauded as a step towards promoting diversity and equality, it has also sparked a heated debate, with some arguing that these practices are discriminatory and unjust.
UBC’s Race-Based Hiring
UBC has announced that it plans to hire five quantitative and environmental science professors based on race, restricting the search to qualified black scholars. According to the university, applicants who wish to be considered for this initiative must self-identify as ‘black’ to be eligible. In addition to being black, interested candidates must also commit to the school’s diversity agenda and include a statement describing their current and future commitments related to equity, diversity, inclusion, and decolonization in their applications.
UVic’s Race-Based Search
Following UBC’s lead, the University of Victoria’s school of music is also limiting its search for a new assistant professor to black scholars. The university is justifying this move by stating that certain groups face barriers to equity and that members of equity-seeking groups should be prioritized in the hiring process. According to UVic, only black people will be considered for the position.
Discrimination or Affirmative Action?
The implementation of race-based hiring initiatives has been met with mixed reactions. While some have welcomed these practices as a progressive step towards addressing historical inequities, others have criticized them as racist and discriminatory. Both universities, however, maintain that their actions are in accordance with section 42 of the BC Human Rights Code, which exempts affirmative action from discrimination claims. They argue that their programs aim to ameliorate the conditions of disadvantaged individuals or groups who are disadvantaged due to race, color, ancestry, or other factors.
The Way Forward
The debate surrounding race-based hiring initiatives underscores the complexity of addressing historical injustices and promoting diversity and inclusion in contemporary society. It forces us to examine the delicate balance between affirmative action and fairness, and challenges us to rethink traditional approaches to achieving equity. While there may not be a straightforward solution, engaging in open, respectful, and inclusive dialogue about these issues is a crucial first step towards envisioning a future where everyone is given equal opportunities.
In conclusion, the implementation of race-based hiring initiatives by UBC and UVic has brought attention to the ongoing conversation about equity and diversity. The debate ignited by these practices highlights the need for meaningful discourse and critical reflection on how we can foster a society that is truly inclusive and just for all.”
Reference
