Melanie Joly denounces Israeli settler violence in West Bank

Melanie Joly condemns Israeli “extremist settler violence” in West Bank


E-mail : *

“Canada Demands Israeli Intervention in Wake of West Bank Violence”

Global Affairs Canada recently expressed grave concerns about the surge in “extremist settler violence” in the West Bank, urging the Israeli government to take swift and decisive action to address the escalating conflict. The significant spike in reported attacks by Israeli settlers against Palestinians has sparked international condemnation and calls for intervention.

The Root of the Conflict

Since the October attack on Israel by Hamas terrorists, the United Nations has observed a notable increase in what it deems as Israeli settler violence in the West Bank. This ongoing dispute is centered around the settlements – communities in historic Judea and Samaria inhabited by approximately 500,000 Jews. The United Nations has long denounced these settlements, categorizing them as illegal, while Israel vehemently rejects this characterization. The latest data released by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) has documented 256 settler attacks against Palestinians, resulting in the displacement of over 1,000 individuals and the destruction of numerous Palestinian households.

The Canadian Stance

Canada, in alignment with the United Nations, views the settlements as illegal and has strongly condemned the reported extremist settler violence. Melanie Joly, Canada’s Foreign Affairs Minister, emphasized the negative impact of such violence on the prospect of achieving a peacefully negotiated two-state solution.

Controversial Views

The escalating violence has not been without controversy. Former Canadian ambassador to Israel, Vivian Bercovici, publicly criticized Joly’s statements, accusing her of focusing obsessively on Israel at the expense of escalating negative reports to appease her HamasISIS base. Complicating the issue further is the lack of nuance in discussions regarding the settlements. Pro-Israel media watchdog Honest Reporting Canada has pointed out the one-sided nature of the discourse, urging a more balanced, nuanced approach and a fair assessment of both Israeli and Palestinian actions.

The Legal Question

Critics argue that Israeli settlements in the West Bank violate the Fourth Geneva Convention, which prohibits an occupying power from transferring parts of its civilian population to the occupied territory. However, defenders of the Israeli settlements assert that there is no occupation, citing the historical Jewish connection to the land and emphasizing the absence of a sovereign Palestinian state.

Seeking a Path to Peace

Global Affairs Canada reiterates its long-standing position and commitment to the pursuit of a comprehensive, just, and lasting peace in the Middle East, underpinned by a two-state solution. The agency emphasizes the need for an independent, viable Palestinian state living peacefully and securely alongside Israel.

Conclusion: A Call for Dialogue

The recent outbreak of violence in the West Bank underscores the urgency of renewing meaningful dialogue and seeking a peaceful, lasting solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. As a complex web of legal, historical, and geopolitical factors continues to shape this dispute, a nuanced, balanced approach is critical to understanding the motives and grievances of all parties involved. Ultimately, it is the responsibility of the international community – and of local leaders and communities – to prioritize dialogue, empathy, and understanding in the pursuit of a sustainable peace in the region.”


Leave a Reply