Scotiabank: Canada’s excessive spending drives up interest rates

Canada's profligate spending forced interest rates higher, Scotiabank says


E-mail : *

“A Monetery Twist: Fiscal Policy and Interest Rates in Canada”

The role and handles of monetary and fiscal policies in Canada have taken an interesting twist in recent years. A team of Scotiabank economists has pointed out that the spending habits of elected officials have resulted in a restrictive monetary policy. According to their calculations, the current 5 per cent interest rate would only be at 3 per cent if it weren’t for the combined program spending and consumption by Canada’s federal and provincial governments since the pandemic. These statements bring to light an important question – what is the impact of fiscal policies on monetary regulations?

A Monetary Dilemma: The Impact of Government Spending

Fiscal spending is a significant factor to consider in the context of monetary policy in Canada. The report from Scotiabank’s economists suggests that the central bank’s key overnight lending rate has been driven up due to government consumption spending and the financial decisions of elected officials. With more balanced fiscal spending, monetary policy wouldn’t be as tight. This observation raises concerns and adds to the ongoing debate about the role of elected officials in influencing the effectiveness of the Bank of Canada’s monetary strategy.

“Rowing in the Same Direction” – Fiscal and Monetary Policy Alignment

The issue does not go unnoticed, as Bank of Canada Governor Tiff Macklem has encouraged elected officials to consider the impact of their fiscal planning on inflation. Alignment between fiscal and monetary policies could potentially ease the financial pressures faced by the Bank. However, as Finance Minister Chrystia Freeland prepares to deliver a fiscal statement, and with provincial governments showing no signs of reining in their spending, the call for improved coordination remains unanswered. The joint responsibility of all levels of government in achieving the 2 per cent inflation target is a matter that demands attention and a reevaluation of the current fiscal policy’s implications on monetary regulations.

A Complicated Task: The Verdict on Fiscal Policy

Scotiabank economists Perrault and Lalonde conclude that fiscal policy has led to “badly mis-calibrated” inflation management since the pandemic. Their analysis places the responsibility on all levels of government for negatively impacting monetary policy. The report compels us to rethink the relationship and boundaries of fiscal and monetary policies and encourages us to consider who holds the key to more balanced financial policies.

It’s evident that there is no easy resolution in sight; it is a complicated dance between appointed and elected officials. As conversations about fiscal and monetary supervision evolve, the fiscal statement in the coming days and the financial climate in the largest province could point the way to a better understanding of this complex relationship.”


Leave a Reply