Alberta panel hears strong calls for province to split from Canada Pension Plan: A no-brainer decision for many

‘No-brainer’: Alberta panel hears callers urge split from Canada Pension Plan


E-mail : *

Panel Hearing Receives Feedback on Alberta Pension Exit

As Alberta considers its potential exit from the Canada Pension Plan, the panel leading the discussion received varied feedback from callers during its recent telethon town hall. The panel, led by former provincial treasurer Jim Dinning, fielded comments and questions from concerned citizens, with opinions split on whether Alberta should pursue its own provincial pension plan.

Support for Alberta’s Own Plan

Multiple callers voiced their support for an Alberta pension plan, citing the need to look out for the best interests of Albertans and keep more resources within the province. A caller from Sherwood Park emphasized the opportunity for Alberta to be a winner rather than continue sending billions of dollars in equalization payments. Similarly, another caller expressed the belief that an Alberta plan would provide a better deal for the province and its residents.

Concerns and Opposition

However, not all callers were in favor of leaving the Canada Pension Plan. Some argued that it was unnecessary to fix something that isn’t broken, pointing to potential challenges and uncertainties with transitioning to a new system. Other concerns included potential opposition from other provinces and whether the government had accurately gauged the public’s interest in the matter.

Reassurance and Clarity

Many callers also voiced the need for more information and reassurance from the government regarding the potential transition. They expressed fears of change and emphasized the importance of conducting surveys and consultations to gauge public interest accurately.

The Path Forward

As the consultation on an Alberta pension plan continues, the panel has promised in-person town halls and further opportunities for feedback. The consultation was launched in response to a report indicating that Alberta’s relatively higher incomes and younger population could make the province well-suited for its own plan.

Moving Forward

With varying opinions and concerns about the potential exit, it is crucial for the government to address the public’s fears and provide clear, transparent information about the path forward. While there may be perceived benefits to an Alberta pension plan, the decision will ultimately impact the lives and financial security of all Albertans. Therefore, careful consideration, thorough consultation, and clarity about the potential risks and rewards are essential in making an informed decision.

As the consultation process continues, it is vital for the government to actively engage with the public, address concerns, and ensure that any decision regarding the pension plan is made in the best interests of Albertans. The potential ramifications of leaving the Canada Pension Plan are significant, and it is essential to weigh all perspectives and thoroughly assess the potential challenges and benefits before moving forward.

The decision on whether to pursue an Alberta stand-alone plan will have lasting implications, and it is crucial to maintain transparency and open dialogue throughout this process. Furthermore, the government must ensure that any decision reflects the values and priorities of Albertans while also considering the broader impact on the country’s retirement system.


Leave a Reply